Can I Choose My Own Body Shop After an Accident in Texas?

A car insurance policy

If you’ve been in a car accident in El Paso, you may be wondering whether you have to use the body shop recommended by your insurance company. The short answer is no. In Texas, you have the right to choose where your vehicle is repaired.

After an accident, things can move quickly. You’re dealing with vehicle damage, an insurance claim, estimates, adjusters, rental transportation, and everything else that comes with trying to get back on the road.

Then your insurance company may provide you with a list of preferred or recommended repair facilities.

That can leave many drivers asking the same question:

Do I have to use the body shop my insurance company recommends?

You Have the Right to Choose Your Body Shop in Texas

Texas law protects a vehicle owner’s ability to select the repair facility they want to use.

Your insurance company may recommend a repair facility or provide a list of preferred shops, but that doesn’t mean you’re required to have your vehicle repaired there.

If you’ve been in an accident in El Paso and want Empire Dent & Body to handle your collision repair, you can choose to bring your vehicle to us.

The most important thing is choosing a repair facility you trust to properly assess the damage and perform the repairs your vehicle needs.

What Is an Insurance “Preferred” Body Shop?

Many insurance companies maintain networks of repair facilities commonly referred to as preferred shops or direct repair facilities.

These shops may have agreements or established procedures with particular insurance companies. Being recommended by an insurance company doesn’t automatically mean a shop is better or worse than another repair facility.

Instead, it’s important to understand that the decision of where to repair your vehicle is ultimately yours.

When choosing a collision repair shop, consider factors such as:

  • Experience with collision repairs
  • Repair quality and procedures
  • Communication throughout the process
  • Local reputation
  • Experience working with insurance claims
  • Your confidence in the people repairing your vehicle

What If the Insurance Estimate Is Lower Than the Body Shop Estimate?

This is extremely common after a collision.

An insurance company’s initial estimate is based on the damage that can be identified during its first inspection. This may involve photographs or a visual inspection of the vehicle.

However, collision damage isn’t always completely visible from the outside.

Once repairs begin and damaged components are removed, technicians may discover additional damage. When that happens, the repair facility can document the additional damage and submit what is known as a supplement to the insurance company.

The insurance company then reviews the additional repair operations and costs.

A difference between the initial insurance estimate and the final repair estimate doesn’t automatically mean something is wrong. Additional damage is often discovered as the vehicle is disassembled and the repair process progresses.

What Is a Collision Repair Supplement?

A collision repair supplement is a request for additional repair costs that weren’t included in the insurance company’s original estimate.

For example, an initial estimate might account for visible damage to a bumper and quarter panel. After disassembly, technicians could discover damage to:

  • Brackets
  • Reinforcement components
  • Sensors
  • Suspension components
  • Other areas that weren’t visible during the initial inspection

Those additional repairs must be properly documented and submitted to the insurance company for review.

This is one reason choosing an experienced collision repair facility matters. A knowledgeable repair team can identify additional accident-related damage and make sure it is properly documented during the repair process.

Can Empire Dent & Body Work With My Insurance Company?

Yes.

At Empire Dent & Body, we regularly work with insurance claims and help customers navigate the collision repair process.

Our team can inspect the vehicle, document damage, prepare the repair estimate, communicate regarding necessary supplemental repairs, and help move the repair process forward.

You don’t need to understand every part of the insurance and repair process before bringing your vehicle to us.

That’s part of what we’re here to help with.

What Should I Look for When Choosing a Body Shop in El Paso?

After an accident, don’t choose a repair facility based solely on convenience.

Look for a shop that provides:

  • Thorough damage inspections
  • Clear communication throughout the repair
  • Proper repair procedures
  • Professional estimating and documentation
  • Experience working with insurance claims
  • Quality body and paint work
  • Modern collision repair equipment
  • A strong local reputation

Most importantly, choose a shop you trust with your vehicle.

Already Have an Insurance Estimate?

If you’ve already received an estimate from your insurance company, you can still bring your vehicle to Empire Dent & Body.

We’ll review the vehicle and the damage and help you understand what comes next.

If additional accident-related damage is discovered during the repair process, it can be documented and submitted to the insurance company for review.

Having an insurance estimate doesn’t mean you have to stop there. A thorough inspection by an experienced collision repair team can help identify repairs that may not have been included in the initial estimate.

Collision Repair in El Paso, Texas

An accident is stressful enough. Choosing where your vehicle gets repaired shouldn’t make it more complicated.

If you’re looking for an experienced auto body shop in El Paso, Empire Dent & Body is here to help you through the collision repair process—from the initial inspection through the final repair.

Been in an accident? Contact Empire Dent & Body or bring us your insurance estimate to get started.

Scroll to Top